What Investors Really Look for in Your Financial Model

A Financial Model Is Your Trust-Building Tool

When you pitch your business to investors, you're not just sharing your idea. You're presenting a financial blueprint of how that idea becomes reality. That blueprint is your financial model.

At Celeste Business Advisors LLP, we've worked with hundreds of startups, agencies, and service businesses to create investor-ready models. We’ve also sat in rooms with VCs and angel investors who grilled founders on the spot. Their questions are sharp, their expectations high, and their time limited.

So, what do investors actually care about when reviewing your financial model?

In this blog, we break down the six most important areas investors focus on. Each section goes deep, highlighting best practices, common red flags, and how to position your numbers with confidence.

This isn’t just about Excel formulas. It’s about telling a financial story that makes investors believe in your business—and in you.

1. Clarity and Structure: Can an Investor Understand It Instantly?

Your financial model is not the place to flex complexity. A clean, easy-to-navigate model is one of the first things investors notice. If they can’t understand the structure in a few minutes, they may not dig deeper.

What Good Clarity Looks Like:

• Clearly labeled tabs: Revenue, Expenses, Assumptions, P&L, Cash Flow, Summary

• Inputs and formulas clearly separated (e.g., blue for inputs, black for formulas)

• No clutter, merged cells, or mystery calculations

Include:

• A one-page dashboard showing revenue, EBITDA, net income, and runway

• A color-coded assumptions tab linked across sheets

• Tooltips or comments explaining complex formulas

Red Flags:

• Hidden cells or broken links

• Overly complex logic with no explanation

• Forecasts with no base assumptions

2. Realistic and Defensible Assumptions

The quality of your assumptions determines the credibility of your entire model. Investors know that your projections won't be perfect, but they do want to see logical, research-backed estimates.

Build Assumptions Around:

• Growth rates based on actual traction or comparable benchmarks

• Customer acquisition cost (CAC) and lifetime value (LTV)

• Headcount growth aligned with revenue

• Customer churn and retention trends

• Pricing models that match your go-to-market approach

Defensible Assumptions:

Use industry reports, historical data, and known benchmarks to validate:

• CAC for your industry and channel

• Payroll costs per region

• Conversion rates from top-of-funnel to close

Red Flags:

• Revenue doubling without marketing spend increasing

• CAC unrealistically low

• No churn forecast for subscription models

• No hiring assumptions despite scaling revenue

3. Revenue Modeling That Ties to Core Drivers

Many founders get tripped up by plugging in arbitrary revenue numbers without logic. Investors want to see revenue models based on real business drivers.

Show How You Earn Revenue:

• SaaS: users × ARPU × retention

• Agencies: billable hours × average rate × utilization rate

• Marketplaces: GMV × take rate

• E-commerce: orders × AOV × conversion rate

Layer in:

• Sales funnel assumptions (e.g., leads to closed deals)

• Sales team hiring to support revenue growth

• Customer onboarding capacity or limits

Red Flags:

• Revenue jumps without GTM explanation

• No link between marketing spend and lead generation

• Flat pricing models despite scaling user base

Tip:

Include scenario modeling to show best, base, and worst-case outcomes with variable drivers.

4. Cost Structure That Reflects Scalability

A strong cost structure shows how your business operates and grows efficiently. Investors will zoom in on how your expenses scale—or don’t—as revenue increases.

Break Costs Into:

• COGS (cost of delivering service/product)

• Operating expenses (sales, marketing, admin)

• Fixed vs. variable costs

• Headcount forecast with timing and salaries

Smart Cost Forecasting:

• Map team hires by role and month

• Account for software, rent, and infrastructure

• Build in inflation or annual pricing increases

Red Flags:

• No cost growth despite scaling team or users

• Employee costs lumped together with no details

• Ignoring indirect costs like benefits, commissions, or training

Investor Question:

What is your contribution margin after variable costs, and how does it change over time?

5. Cash Flow and Burn Rate Transparency

Cash is king—especially in early-stage businesses. A clear view of cash flow tells investors how long you can operate, when you’ll need more funding, and what milestones you’ll hit before then.

Include in Cash Flow Forecast:

• Cash inflows (revenue collection timing, funding rounds)

• Cash outflows (payroll, vendors, marketing)

• Working capital needs (accounts receivable/payable)

• Burn rate and runway metrics

Best Practices:

• Use monthly cash flow forecasts for 12–24 months

• Separate one-time expenses (e.g., legal, rebranding)

• Model runway both pre- and post-funding

Red Flags:

• No forecast beyond 6 months

• No plan for future capital requirements

• Unrealistic collection assumptions (e.g., all clients pay instantly)

6. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) That Show Business Health

After reviewing your model’s logic, investors look at the metrics that matter most. These KPIs show whether your model supports a sustainable, scalable business.

Critical KPIs to Include:

• MRR/ARR (for recurring revenue businesses)

• CAC, LTV, LTV:CAC ratio

• Customer churn and retention

• Revenue per employee

• Gross margin and EBITDA margin

• CAC payback period (goal: under 12 months for SaaS)

Dashboard Format:

Build a clean, visual dashboard with monthly trends and 3–5 year projections. Investors should be able to scan this and get your business health at a glance.

Red Flags:

• LTV:CAC ratio below 2:1

• High churn with no retention strategy

• Flat margins over time

• Metrics not tied to actual model data

Conclusion: A Financial Model That Tells the Right Story

Your model isn’t about perfect predictions—it’s about building investor confidence.

A good financial model tells a story: one of growth, control, and investability. It connects your vision to numbers and your numbers to execution.

Make sure it’s:

• Clear and professional

• Built on logic and real assumptions

• Scalable, realistic, and fundable

• Focused on cash and metrics

Need Help Building a Financial Model Investors Will Trust?

At Celeste Business Advisors LLP, we: Build custom financial models from scratch for fundraising Review and refine existing models for VC and angel pitches Guide you through CAC, runway, and revenue modeling with clarity.

📞 Book a call today Or 📩 email us at consulting@celesteadvisory.com Let’s turn your spreadsheet into your most persuasive pitch.

Celeste Business Advisors is proudly Fathom Certified, XERO Certified,

QBO Certified, and our team includes seasoned CPAs and CMAs to provide comprehensive financial guidance.

Click Here For A Free Consultation With Our Expert